Thursday, March 31, 2011

American Idol Season 10: The Top 11 (Again!) Interpret Elton John

The show opened in true dramatic form as always because now that the "Judge's Save" has been used, there are no more second chances.



01 Scotty McCreery sang Country Comfort-- Steven said you didn't it again for me. Jennifer said you have amazing instincts about performing, you're right on, never doubt yourself. Randy said it's like you are already a seasoned performer, and I am at your show. Scotty is brave because he takes songs that have a really different sound and he makes them his own.
Score: 9

02 Naima Adedapo sang I'm Still Standing-- Jennifer said I don't know if that song should have been flipped, but I love how you performed. Randy said it came off kind of corny and that's not who you are. Steven said good for you for picking a song that actually fits you. I actually think she took a risk and it paid off. I agree with Steven; I liked what she brought to the song.
Score: 9

03 Paul McDonald sang Rocket Man-- Randy said I think you're holding back; I want you to push more. Jennifer echoed the sentiment. Steven said I loved your voice and the day you start hitting every note I am not going to like you anymore. I can name five singers out there right now that don't hit every note, and that's my cup of tea. I like you; I like your character. I don't think this was Paul's best performance by a long shot, but he does deserve to be here.
Score: 7

04 Pia Toscano sang Don't Let the Sun Go Down on Me-- Steven said ballads are who you are. Jennifer said I feel you trying to push through that barrier on the performance side of things. Randy made it clear that Pia can sing, he just wants her to show more of what she has to offer by singing different types of songs. To me, Pia is one of the most consistent people in this competition and she definitely makes the right song choices to showcase her vocal skills.
Score: 9

05 Stefano Langone sang Tiny Dancer-- Jennifer said I felt you moved the crowd today; you made a connection. Randy said I liked that you made a connection with the audience, you moved around the stage, and you hit the money notes every time. Steven said, you nailed it, you connected with the audience; it was really good. Stefano has proven that he can take feedback and criticism and turn it around into a positive performance. This is something that real stars do and he doesn't deserve to be in that bottom three this week.
Score: 9.5

06 Lauren Alaina sang Candle in the Wind-- Randy called it one of the best Lauren Alaina performances and said she is a pro who can do anything if she believes in herself. He said it was very hot. Steven said we knew what you were about the first night we met you and that was perfect. Jennifer said that was amazing, you sounded gorgeous, that was "it" baby; best of the night. Lauren's performance was really unforgettable tonight, she proved that she has star quality.
Score: 10

07 James Durbin sang Saturday Night's All Right-- Steven said you brought the heat, you go where other people don't go, you have a great rock voice. Jennifer and Randy both said that it was a great performance. He got everyone involved to the point that they forgot it was a competition.
Score: 10

08 Thia Megia sang Daniel-- Randy said there were some pitch issues here and there and it may have been a little bit too safe. Jennifer and Steven both agreed that she picked the right song for her voice. I think Thia has been spared one too many times, and I don't think any of her performances have been strong enough to warrant her going any further. She is a really sweet girl though.
Score: 7

09 Casey Abrams sang Your Song-- Randy said saving you was one of the greatest saves we've had on this show. Your performance was tender, well done. Steven said, you sing different every time and that's what a great artist does. Jennifer said I didn't lose an ounce of sleep saving you; your performance tonight was sweet. I still don't think this was Casey's best but it is leaps in the right direction. The Casey I loved before is definitely back.
Score: 9.5

10 Jacob Lusk sang Sorry Seems to be the Hardest Word-- Steven loved the whole performance. Jennifer loved the arrangement of the song, and the final note; she called it very Jacob. Randy said pick one spot in the song where you go all the way because the first half of the performance was great. I have a lot of friends who think Casey is a lock to win this thing, but I told them to be weary of certain people, and one of them is Jacob and this performance has proven that.
Score: 10

11 Haley Reinhart sang Benny and the Jets-- Jennifer said it all came together for you tonight, amazing. Randy called it the best performance of the night. Steven said, you sing sexy. I agree this was by far Haley's performance but I don't know if it redeems her or saves her from a string of not so good performances.
Score: 10 (for tonight)

I have no clue who should be going home tonight. I just hope the public got it right.

Wednesday, March 23, 2011

American Idol Season 10: The Top 11 Take Motown

Tonight began with an homage to Motown Records which produced over 400 hit singles and 50 number one hits! Berry Gordy sat in the audience looking on.

01. Casey Abrams sang "I Heard it Through the Grapevine" by Marvin Gaye (1967)-- Steven said perfect pitch and perfect mix of out of control. Jennifer said, I thought about it and there is no one out there like you. Randy said you're a true original and you take chances. I liked it, but I have to be honest; I didn't love this performance. I kept trying to figure out why and I discovered it's because to me the vocals felt forced in places. It didn't feel effortless to me.
Score: 8

02. Thia Megia sang "Heat Wave" by Martha Reeves and the Vandellas (1963)-- Jennifer said continue to dig deeper because we know you have it in you, and remember to connect with your lyrics. Randy said you can really sing but keep pushing. Steven said, you took a step out, and I'm good with it. Thia did improve from last week; however, her vocals continue to be on the weak side. She has a ways to go, and if it doesn't change or improve, she'll only be around for a couple more weeks.
Score: 7

03. Jacob Lusk sang "You're All I Need to Get By" by Marvin Gaye and Tammi Terrell (1968)-- Randy said you were a true professional and there was nothing wrong with that performance. Jennifer said you made us beg and you moved us. Steven said it was beautiful and ran up onstage to hug Jacob when it was over. I didn't want this performance to be over, like Jennifer, my ears were standing at attention waiting for more. This was truly a polished performance; bravo!
Score: 10

04. Lauren Alaina sang "You Keep Me Hanging On" by The Supremes (1966)-- Steven said every time you said I hear that person inside of you, it was beautiful. Jennifer thought Lauren looked beautiful and loved the attitude that she brought to the song. Randy said Lauren is back and she has her swagger on tonight. I felt she did a good job singing the song and her vocals were solid, but there was a part of me that kept expecting her to do more with the song.
Score: 8.5

05. Stefano Langone sang "Hello" by Lionel Richie (1984)-- Jennifer said, fine, check, sing like crazy, check, all that's missing is your connection with the audience. She said when you feel it in your heart, your phrasing is going to change. You have to be able to connect with the song emotionally, look at every lyric, if you don't make a connection, throw it out, and move on to the next song. Steven agreed with Jennifer. Randy said you sounded really good but there was no real connection. I have to say, I think the advice Jennifer gave to Stefano was spot on. He is one of the best singers in the competition, imagine how much better he will be once he makes that connection. Wow!
Score: 9

06. Hayley Reinhart sang "You Really Got a Hold on Me" by Smokey Robinson and the Miracles (1962)-- Randy said it started rough but by the middle of the song the bluesy Hayley we knew and loved in Hollywood came back. Steven said, it was beautiful and touched my heart. Jennifer said you have an effortless control in your voice and the most soulful female voice in the competition. This was leaps and bounds better than any performance I have seen from her thus far. The question is, is it strong enough to keep her in the competition? That's a toss up.
Score: 8

07. Scotty McCreery sang "For Once in My Life" by Stevie Wonder (1968)-- Steven said, Scotty that was beautiful, you took a chance. Jennifer said it wasn't your best performance but it was a great version of the song and every time you hit that low note, you get me all over again. Randy said not your best vocal, but you made it your own. What I love about Scotty, and I may sound like a broken record, is that he stays true to who he is, and he does what he does well.
Score: 9

08. Pia Toscano sang "All in Love is Fair" by Stevie Wonder (1973)-- Jennifer said, same thing she said to Stefano, look and beauty, check, voice, check, feeling, check, and now all that is missing is the stage presence. You're going to need to have that because someday you're going to do a two hour concert. Randy said your voice is phenomenal and he wants to hear something other than a ballad. Steven said you are the closest star in this American Idol thing, and I know you'll do whatever it takes to prove how great you are. That was unbelievable to me, that was a performance that brought a tear to my eyes. That is what you call effortless vocals.
Score: 10

09. Paul McDonald sang "Tracks of My Tears" by Smokey Robinson and The Miracles (1965)-- Randy said you're so unique and I love that tender part of your voice at the end. Steven said I loved what you did tonight, especially with the guitar onstage. Jennifer said you're the most seasoned performer, you come out, do your thing, all you need is a producer. The distinctness of Paul's voice is what draws me in every week, it completely captures me. I love the high performance quality and he is more comfortable onstage than anyone else.
Score: 8.9

10. Naima Adedapo sang "Dancing in the Street" by Martha Reeves and the Vandellas (1964)-- Steven said this is the whole package. Jennifer said you're an exciting performer, you're my mover, my shaker, and my dancer. Randy said I know I have been hard on you these past few weeks but tonight, all of Naima showed up, and everything you did was smart. This was 100% pure fun and pure talent for me. I loved that everything was so well put together.
Score: 9.5

11. James Durbin sang "Living for the City" by Stevie Wonder (1973)-- Jennifer said you are serious business up there. Randy said when you hit your pocket, you were unbelievable. Steven said your voice was incredible. James has that great rocker voice, and his voice is always once I look forward to hearing every week.
Score: 10

Wednesday, March 16, 2011

The Top 12 American Idol Season 10: Songs From The Year You Were Born

The show kicked off poignantly with the judges talking about the tragedy in Japan with purchases of tonight's singles going to aid efforts. The theme tonight is "Songs from the Year You Were Born".

01. Naima Adedapo(1984) sang "What's Love Got to do With It" by Tina Turner-- I don't think I loved this because it seems like Naima had trouble this week with the same thing she had trouble with last week. The pitch was just all over the place. Steven said she has a sorcerer's grasp for melody. Jennifer said she was under the pitch and has to work on that. Randy agreed and said you looked hot but the vocals were all over the place.
Score: 6

02. Paul McDonald (1984) sang "I Guess That's Why They Call it the Blues" by Elton John-- I could tell that Paul struggled being sick and all but despite all that he has definite potential and sounded good. Jennifer said it sounded so good, you have so much soul, and so much star quality. Randy said the notes were a little pitchy but you make everything you sing your own. Steven said you define a cool dude, I love your swagger, and you have such a distinctive voice.
Score: 8

03. Thia Megia (1995) sang "Colors of the Wind" by Vanessa Williams-- Unfortunately, this was painful for me to listen to. Thia's voice was too small and this just ended up being boring for me. Randy said the vocals were okay, but he found it boring, there was nothing special about it, and it was too safe. Steven asked her to think if this song is really who she is. Jennifer said this was too safe, you need to break out from that, push out of the box.
Score: 5

04. James Durbin (1989) sang "I'll Be There for You" by Bon Jovi-- This wasn't James's best performance but he makes me smile every time he takes the stage. He continues to be passionate and grow in his performance quality. Steven said it was good James but don't get too poppy on me. Jennifer said you make me wanna sing along and you bring so much joy when you're up on the stage. Randy said the high note was very tastefully done, it was a little pitchy, but I liked that you found a way to make it your own.
Score: 9.5

05. Haley Reinhart (1990) sang "I'm Your Baby Tonight" by Whitney Houston-- This is a classic R&B song and Haley strayed too far from that. The melody of the song was lost, and the vocals were far from being on point. Jennifer commented on how beautiful Haley looked. Randy said I'm not sure that you are sure of who you are as an artist. He said that the vocals were okay but it wasn't a great performance. Steven told her to dig into the blues part of her.
Score: 6

06. Stefano Langone (1989) sang "If You Don't Know Me By Now" by Simply Red-- Stefano impressed me with his vocals in his song, he did dig deep and he showed lots of emotion. Randy said this was the best performance of the night, hot vocals! Steven commented on the beautiful phrasing that Stefano put together in his performance. Jennifer loved it and said if he works on his connection with the audience this competition is his.
Score: 10

07. Pia Toscano (1988) sang "Where Do Broken Hearts Go" by Whitney Houston-- Pia is consistent, and arguably the best female singer in this competition. Clearly, she knows who she is as an artist. Steven said, Pia, you took that song over the top. Jennifer said I liked that you gave an upbeat performance this time. Randy said hey everyone Pia is in this competition to win it.
Score: 9

08. Scotty McCreery (1993) sang "Can I Trust You With My Heart" by Travis Tritt-- Scotty is going to be a huge star, and not just in the country world but in general. This kid is crazy good and he knows who he is with no doubts and his vocals are always on. Jennifer likes how Scotty continues to grow and she urged him to keep growing and keep learning. Randy said you did Travis proud and I believe in you. Steven said, you are gonna go places.
Score: 10

09. Karen Rodriguez (1989) sang "Love Will Lead You Back" by Taylor Dane-- Karen showed me tonight why she is in this competition, not only did I enjoy her performance but I thought her vocals were exceptional. Randy said welcome back Karen. Steven said this was tan dolce. Jennifer liked how she attacked it and told her to perform to her strengths.
Score: 9.75

10. Casey Abrams (1991) sang "Smells Like Teen Spirit" by Nirvana-- This to me was a big risk that paid off big time. I loved this, and it shows me how versatile a performer Casey is. Steven said you're crazy and talented and that's the perfect combination. Jennifer said big shoes to fill, and it was a big risk, it lacked a little bit of intensity at times, but I still love you. Randy said the thing he likes about Casey is he thinks big risk first and commerce second, and he is fearless.
Score: 9.75

11. Lauren Alaina (1994) sang "I'm The Only One" by Melissa Etheridge-- Despite the fact that Lauren is sick she still managed to sound good. This young lady has lots of poise. Jennifer said you kept with the melody of this song, yet you made it your own. Randy said despite being sick he liked what she did this week. Steven said Lauren, you're a shining star; you did it again.
Score: 9

12. Jacob Lusk (1987) sang "Alone" by Heart-- Jacob is back tonight and in top form. I loved his rendition of "Alone", he took it to church like I thought he would. Randy said you lost your way for like two bars but then you found your way back quick. Steven said the gospel had a baby and named it Jacob Lusk. Jennifer said you give yourself completely to every performance.
Score: 9.75

My prediction for the bottom 3: Thia, Naima, and Haley

Power Rankings (after tonight's performances)
1. Scotty
1. Stefano
2. Pia
2. Casey
2. Jacob
3. Karen
3. James
3. Lauren
9. Paul
10. Naima
11. Thia
12. Haley

Wednesday, March 9, 2011

The Top 13 American Idol Season 10: Songs from their Idols

1. Lauren Alaina sang "Any Man of Mine" by Shania Twain-- Lauren Alaina has a wonderful performance quality about her and she can sing just about anything. What is missing right now is the fire and desire within her to win this competition. Steven said I love that song but it should have been a little bit more kick ass. Randy said we want you to sing something that will make you shine beyond belief because we know you have that talent. Jennifer said we love you but we want to see that you want it.
Score: 9.75

2. Casey Abrams sang "With a Little Help from My Friends" by Joe Cocker-- I liked this performance very much, but I did not by any means feel it was one of his best performances. Jennifer felt that Casey blew her away! Randy said I always look forward to seeing you sing. You make it fun and I loved it. Steven said you're a rainbow of talent, and I love what you do, you're a plethora of passion.
Score: 8

3. Ashthon Jones sang "When You Tell Me That You Love Me" by Diana Ross-- Randy said you grew as a singer in that performance. Jennifer felt the song wasn't well known enough but still thinks Ashthon is amazing. Steven has confidence in her. I felt this performance was forgettable at best, it was okay but nothing special.
Score: 7

4. Paul McDonald sang "Come Pick Me Up" by Ryan Adams-- I did not love this song choice but I love Paul. I love his character and I love who he is as a person and what he brings to the Idol stage. I don't think there has ever been anyone like him on the show before. Steven said love the character and rasp in your voice, a lil pitchy, watch out. Jennifer felt he was unique and moved the crowd. Randy said I love the character of you and I love Ryan Adams.
Score: 8.5

5. Pia Toscano sang "All By Myself" by Celine Dion-- I think Pia is a rare find and I have felt that since the beginning. Her voice can tackle all those Mariah, Whitney, and Celine songs without question. Jennifer felt she topped last week, really beautiful. Randy said you hit all the notes dead on and you have such a natural gift. Hot, dope, cool performance; I agree. Happy International Women's Day, you slammed that Pia, it was beautiful, said Steven.
Score: 10

6. James Durbin sang "Maybe I'm Amazed" by Paul McCartney-- This is a guy who I really like because he has no ego and he just goes out there and sings his butt off every week. I admire James and I am inspired by him. Listen man, you are one of my favorites and let me tell you why; you can sing anything. James Durbin is dangerous America, this man can sing! Steven said you did such a good job. Jennifer said you have what the best rock singers have, a melodic quality to your voice.
Score: 10+

7. Haley Reinhart sang "Blue" by Leann Rimes-- In appreciate the raspy quality of Haley's voice and it's something I really like. That being said, I agree with Randy, it was a little bit boring. Haley does not want to become average at this stage of the competition. Steven said Haley that was beautiful and you did such a good job. Jennifer loves that her voice is so special.
Score: 8.75

8. Jacob Lusk sang "I Believe I Can Fly" by R. Kelly-- Again, I am going to have to agree with Randy. Jacob has this signature start to every song where he opens his mouth and you can tell that it's him singing. The middle of the song he lost his way a bit, and it was a little pitchy, but in the end he found his way again. I loved the way this performance ended. Jennifer said, you're amazing Jacob. Steven said, I cannot even judge you cause you're that good.
Score: 8

9. Thia Megia sang "Smile" by Michael Jackson-- Randy loved the beginning and felt Thia had a sound reminscent to Michael Jackson and Adele; he didn't like the jazzy part in the middle and end. Steven echoed Randy. Jennifer said I too didn't get the arrangement but you still sounded like an angel. I agree, the arrangement was a bit of a mess and that could end up hurting Thia. I loved the soft quality in her voice that we heard in the beginning but that middle part, it just wasn't her.
Score: 7.5

10. Stefano Langone sang "Lately" by Stevie Wonder-- Steven said you pulled that off, and it was so well done. Jennifer said she was dancing, and said it was like the dance remix of Lately. She also commented that he sounded great. Randy said, Stevie is one of the greatest male singers even and he felt Stevie would be proud of that performance; by the middle, you were soaring. I didn't love the arrangement of this song, but I think Stefano sounded amazing. He always sings like he is fighting for his life; it's nice to see someone with that much desire.
Score: 9.75

11. Karen Rodriguez sang "I Could Fall in Love" by Selena-- Jennifer hit it dead on and I agree with her; she said I felt you were uncomfortable with a lot of the notes and I have never known you to have trouble with hitting notes. Randy said it felt like you were fighting the song and it felt a little bit sleepy. Steven said I know you can do much better.
Score: 7

12. Scotty McCreery sang "The River" by Garth Brooks-- Randy said if it ain't broke, don't even consider fixing it. This is where you belong, you could put this out as a record right now, I love it, don't change it. Amen Randy! This was one of the best performances of the night and I am convinced that this young man is going to be a star in country music. Steven said, you are ridin high. Jennifer said what I loved is how you really opened up and brought the audience into this with you.
Score: 10

13. Naima Adedapo sang "Umbrella" by Rihanna-- I give this young woman major props for originality and for going out there and doing something that no one else did. All the areas where she was singing, I was very impressed with her voice. I thought her voice was beautiful. Steven said you were a little pitchy but you brought flavor and I adore you for that. Jennifer liked her fire and said you're doing it like a real artist. Work on your control though she said. Randy said I do care about the pitchiness but I loved what you brought to the performance.
Score: 9.25

Thursday, March 3, 2011

American Idol Season 10: Top 24 Part 2

The Ladies:

1. TaTynisa Wilson sang Only Girl in the World by Rihanna-- Steven liked it a lot. Jennifer told her that she brought it home. Randy thought it was okay, nothing special or different about it; I agree with Randy.
Score: 5

2. Naima Adedapo sang Summertime by Porgy and Bess-- Randy liked how Naima ended the song. Steven said she sounds like a new Ella Fitzgerald. I like the sound of Naima; I don't know if she is strong enough for this competition.
Score: 8

3. Kendra Chantelle sang Impossible by Christina Aguilera-- Randy said he really liked it and Steven called her the whole package. Jennifer thinks that Kendra can give more than that, and I agree but I think she is stronger than most of the other ladies from this season.
Score: 9

4. Rachel Zevita sang Criminal by Fiona Apple-- Steven found it to be too Broadway. Randy called it not good at all and said Fiona's song was unrecognizable. Jennifer said when you're on stage you have to think about what people are going to think of you.
Score: 4

5. Karen Rodriguez sang Hero by Mariah Carey-- Randy said she found a way to make it her own especially by bringing the Spanish into it. He said it sounded beautiful with the Spanish. Steven said I just loved it and I think you're fantastic.
Score: 9

6. Lauren Turner sang Seven Day Fool by Etta James-- Steven said it was like Lauren Turner meets Lauren Turner. Jennifer said her voice is undeniable. Randy said it was like Amy Winehouse meets Florence and the Machine. I think Lauren has one of the stronger voices in this competition.
Score: 8

7. Ashthon Jones sang Love Over Me by Monica-- Jennifer said you have the makings of a diva. Steven said you go places with your voice that other people don't go. Randy complimented on her confidence and stage presence. Ashthon should have sang something more recognizable so that people would have been able to relate more because I think she is extremely talented.
Score: 9

8. Julie Zorilla sang Breakaway by Kelly Clarkson-- Jennifer liked it but didn't love it. She said you needed to connect with the words more. Randy said it wasn't new, different, or better than Kelly. Steven said it was the wrong song for you.
Score: 7

9. Haley Reinhart sang Fallin' by Alicia Keys-- Randy said the song did nothing for you; it was karaoke. Steven said it was great and Jennifer said we saw a lot of the things that make you who you are. I like Haley but I didn't think the growling was necessary in this song.
Score: 7

10. Thia Megia sang Out Here On My Own by Irene Cara-- Jennifer called it captivating and Randy said her tone is like that of Michael Jackson, and that is what hot singing is all about. I have to say I enjoy Thia's quiet presence.
Score: 9.25

11. Lauren Alaina sang Turn on the Radio by Reba McEntire-- Jennifer said you're so naturally good. Randy said you don't even know how good you are, you're like Kelly meets Carrie. Steven said I love you, you're the best, your voice goes from here to there, and we haven't seen the best of you yet.
Score: 9.5

12. Pia Toscano sang I'll Stand by You by The Pretenders-- Randy said that was unbelievable and all the judges gave her a standing ovation. Steven called it gorgeous. Jennifer said I knew you were a stand out and that was out of this world. I have to say for me, that was one of the strongest performances by a female singer on American Idol ever.
Score: 10

American Idol Season 10: Top 24

American Idol Season 10 started off by introducing the public to the Top 24 for the first time.

On Tuesday the Top 12 Guys performed and on Wednesday the Top 12 Ladies performed; my overall opinion is that the guys outperformed the ladies by a mile. I will say that the ladies overall are more impressive than past seasons. The guys are more well rounded, they are not just singers but musicians.

These are my predictions for the Top 10 (in random order):
James Durbin
Scotty McCreery
Paul McDonald
Jacob Lusk
Casey Abrams
Ashthon Jones
Karen Rodriguez
Thia Megia
Lauren Alaina
Pia Toscano

These are my Wild Card Picks:
Guys: (will be between these 3)
Tim Halperin
Robbie Rosen
Stefano Langone
Ladies: (will be between these 3)
Naima Adedapo
Kendra Chantelle
Julie Zorilla

Here's a brief recap:

1. Clint Jun Gamboa sang Superstition by Stevie Wonder-- A little bit amateurish to me, it seemed like an amateur wanting to be a star. Jennifer said it was good and worked the nerves out. Randy said it wasn't karaoke.
Score (out of 10, 10 being the best): 6

2. Jovany Bareto sang I'll Be by Edwin McCain-- I liked this but I definitely didn't love it. Edwin McCain is a huge fan of the show and I don't know that he would have liked this. Randy said this felt very karaoke and it was not better than the original.
Score: 5

3. Jordan Dorsey sang OMG! by Usher-- This was painful to listen to and watch, and it's a shame because he chose the wrong song. He should have picked something like What's Goin On by Marvin Gaye or Power of Love by Luther Vandross. Jennifer said the song wasn't you. Randy called it pitchy and all over the place. Steven said this was not my favorite performance of you.
Score: 5

4. Tim Halperin sang Streetcorner Symphony by Rob Thomas-- Steven said the song let him down. Jennifer said the song didn't show people who he is as an artist. Randy echoed the other two judges. Tim sang the chorus strongly but the verses were weak at best.
Score: 7.5

5. Brett Lowenstern sang Light my Fire by The Doors-- This song is way too old for him; he should have been singing something more contemporary. He agreed that there were some problems, especially at the beginning of the performance when asked by the judges.
Score: 7

6. James Durbin sang You Got Another Thing Comin' by Judas Priest-- Steven called it f****n crazy good. Jennifer called it real, natural, and said it comes from the inside. I expected James to be this good because I think he wants it more than most people.
Score: 10

7. Robbie Rosen sang Angel by Sara McLachlin-- Steven said you sing ballads like no one's business. Jennifer said when you sing you tell a story, you are a very special singer. Randy said you never quite settled into the performance. I feel that all the judges were correct.
Score: 8

8. Scotty McCreery sang Letters from Home by John Michael Montgomery-- Steven said you couldn't have picked a better song. Jennifer said you are born to sing country music. Randy said he made a nice choice. I have to say that when I watch Scotty sing and when I hear him, I can tell that he has a great love for singing and music.
Score: 9.5

9. Stefano Langone sang Just the Way You Are by Bruno Mars-- Steven said, loved you; you are so good. Jennifer said there's nothing awkward about you up there. Randy said keep in mind we're looking for someone who can be on the radio right now and you have that. I really liked Stefano but I don't think this was the correct choice of song for him. He may make it in based on the girls just loving him.
Score: 8.5

10. Paul McDonald sang Maggie May by Rod Stewart-- Paul sang this song different from Rod Stewart yet he kept the melody of the song. Steven said he loved the character of his voice. Jennifer said I love that you smile when you sing, it was a good performance. Randy said I'm a fan and I don't think we've ever had someone like you in the competition ever before.
Score: 9

11. Jacob Lusk sang A House is Not A Home by Luther Vandross-- Steven said I'm honored to be in your presence, you make me wanna cry, whatever you have, I wanna bathe in it. Randy said I think we're so lucky to have you and you did Luther proud. Jennifer said Luther was my favorite of all time and he's gone, but now we have you, and that's the amazing thing about this show.
Score: 10

12. Casey Abrams sang I Put a Spell on You by Screamin Jay Hawkins-- Casey has the ability to make me smile when he sings no matter what he sings. Steven said in your mind good and ourof your mind real. Jennifer called him sexy and said she could tell he wants this; she loved it. Randy said you tranform yourself into the spirit of the song.
Score: 10

See part 2 for a recap of the ladies performances.