Carrie Underwood opened the show with a killer rendition of Alone by Heart just like she sang twenty years ago!
Filo sang With a Little Help from My Friends by Joe Cocker-- Loved this rendition, masterful is the word I'd use I think. What a great song choice, he continues to just knock it out of the park. Carrie felt like he took an iconic song and make it his own. Luke said he could not say anything bad about that performance.
Mattie Pruitt sang Piece of My Heart by Janis Joplin-- She is lucky that she has such a great voice and still delivered the rasp because that song lacked the emotion it really needed. You have to have experienced "life" to sing that song. James Taylor (who mentored the contestants this week) said typically a woman, not a teenager sings that song.
John Foster sang Jailhouse Rock by Elvis Presley-- This could have been super cheese or karaoke but it wasn't! He made an American Classic his own. Carrie said it was believable and he made the song his own.
Desmond Roberts sang Jesus is Love by The Commodores-- I think Desmond is so talented but I think the song, was very challenging, and unfortunately, and Luke noted it, there were a lot of pitchy moments. I want him to stay in the competition, but this might be it for him.
Jamal Roberts sang Shout by The Isley Brothers-- Jamal brings us to a party every time he takes the stage. This was inspired, genuine, and energetic. Carrie said it was the perfect song choice, Luke called it "smart", and Lionel called the performance "professional".
Amanda Barise sang I Can't Help It by Michael Jackson-- I don't think this was the right song choice for her. I think she needed to sing more of a power ballad, especially since she has been vulnerable in this competition. The judges all thought she nailed it.
Canaan James Hill sang Mary Don't You Weep by Aretha Franklin-- Great song choice, solid performance. The judges suggest he should try something out of his wheelhouse or box, and I don't know that I agree with that. I like that Canaan knows who he is. Carrie said she wants to see him do something unexpected at some point.
Josh King sang The Longest Time by Billy Joel-- Another solid song choice suited to his style. This was awesome, I loved James Taylor's feedback. Carrie makes the comment that he knows who he is and what a great song choice that was (this reinforces what I was saying about Canaan). Luke called him charming and endearing. Lionel encouraged him to push himself because he has the talent.
Thunderstorm Artis sang Fire and Rain by James Taylor-- In theory, it was a good song choice. His voice sounded a little hoarse. Unsure if maybe he was dealing with being sick. The way he changed up the song to suit his style was really cool, and James Taylor complimented him on that. Luke said it had hints of James Taylor but a lot of him. I agree. He should stick around in the competition, but he needs to sharpen the vocals.
Gabby Samone sang Saving All My Love by Whitney Houston-- Wow! She has turned me into a mega fan. I loved this performance. She sounded amazing. She did not copy Whitney. That was the ultimate tribute. Lionel called it phenomenal.
Breanna Nix sang Open Arms by Journey-- This was a big improvement over Queen last week. I agree with the judges in that she might be overcomplicating things and overthinking. The performance started great and towards the end it started to get away from her.
Kolbi Jordan sang You're All I Need to Get By by Tammi Terrell and Marvin Gaye-- She was back in full force this week after a mediocre couple of weeks. This was a strong choice and told a lot about who she is as an artist. Luke felt everything was there and noted her confidence; he said you've arrived. Carrie said we are spoiled on this show, there is so much talent.
Che Chesterman sang It's a Man's World by James Brown-- Hmmm, I liked this performance but I didn't love it. I have heard many great renditions of this song and this was good not great. Carrie mentioned something like this as well, that she wanted him to rock out and take it to the next level. I agree, couldn't agree more.
Slater Nalley sang Your Song by Elton John-- It was cool for him to do a country version of this song. He's unique, definitely an old soul. Carrie said it was a great song choice and I liked seeing you get emotional with James Taylor. Luke said the fact that you're 18 and this cool, makes me mad. The vibe of that song puts you in the right light, you have the maturity to deliver that at your age. Lionel urged people to vote.
Desmond and Amanda were sent home.
I am thinking Breanna and Che could be next to go, maybe even Thunderstorm. The Top 10 are announced tonight and Fantasia mentors.
No comments:
Post a Comment